The Barbarian Village acts as a perfect "combat simulator." Because the barbarian army compositions are predictable, you can use these battles to:
Mastering the Frontier: Why Upgrading Your Ikariam Barbarian Village is a Game-Changer ikariam barbarian village better
This is where it becomes "better" than player raiding. The resource-to-loss ratio is highly favorable if you use a balanced frontline. The Barbarian Village acts as a perfect "combat simulator